Tag Archives: Gettysburg

Debunking Myths of Gettysburg

Rick Klein, Jordyn Phelps and Nick Poppy in Yahoonews.com, June 29, 2013:

For something that happened 150 years ago, the Battle of Gettysburg still generates its share of controversy. And myth, according to historian Allen Guelzo, “grows like weed out of controversy.”

Guelzo, a professor of history at – appropriately enough – Gettysburg College, is the author of the recently published “Gettysburg: The Last Invasion.” He spoke with ABC News Political Director Rick Klein about the battle and his book – an exhaustively researched and detailed dive into the pivotal fight of the Civil War.

Among the myths of Gettysburg that Guelzo debunks is that the battle was an accident – that Robert E. Lee’s Army of Northern Virginia and George Gordon Meade’s Army of the Potomac merely happened upon each other in the hills of South Central Pennsylvania. “No, it was not really an accident,” said Guelzo. “At least not more of an accident than any battle in the Civil War was.”

Guelzo’s book also restores the reputation of J.E.B. Stuart, cavalry commander of the Confederate Army. “Did he [Stuart] really render Robert E. Lee blind by riding on a joy ride almost entirely out of the campaign?” Guelzo asked. Over the years, Stuart has come in for much criticism for his cavalry’s supposed abandonment of Lee’s main force. “That also is an exaggeration, if not an outright myth.”

“There are a number of other myths,” Guelzo offered. “That the 20th Maine volunteers and Joshua Lawrence Chamberlain saved the Union at Little Round Top. Well, all honor to Chamberlain and his men, they did do the right thing at Little Round Top on July 2nd,” by defending their position with a bayonet charge.

“But actually,” according to the historian, “Chamberlain was one of only a series of junior officers who make decisions like that…[to] save the future of the army and the country, at Gettysburg. He is one face in a crowd of people who make those spontaneous right decisions.”

Guelzo described the battle as “a galaxy of marvelous stories. It’s about people fighting small-scale fights within the big battle, and they’re doing it very much on their own initiative, they’re doing it without direction from famous-named generals, and…they’re making the right decision on their own by just doing it, time after time after time.”

Placed next to more recent fighting, like that seen in Iraq or Afghanistan, Guelzo suggested “you won’t recognize what combat in Gettysburg looked like. The Battle of Gettysburg was more a species of the old Napoleonic kind of conflict, the old 18th century kind of war, than it was modern warfare. Simply because the weapons technology of the period dictated that.”

Communications technology was different as well, of course. In an age when the idea of telecommunications was confined to telegraphs and hand-delivered messages, even President Lincoln had no way of knowing the outcome of Gettysburg until 24 hours after the battle was over. Guelzo likened the president to a “prospective father in the waiting room. Trying to find out about this big event that’s occurring that he can’t see, or can’t be part of, that he just has to wait for.”

Lincoln got word of the Union victory at Gettysburg at nearly the same moment he also heard of the surrender of the Confederate citadel at Vicksburg. “Those two victories together give Abraham Lincoln the best weekend that he’s had during the war, if not during his life,” said Guelzo.

Gettysburg was “a decisive moment in the middle of the decisive moment of the American Civil War…Up to that point, the Confederacy have been putting on quite a good show for its bid for independence. These breakaway Southern states had formed their own government, formed their own armies, they had sustained defeats, but in the East, the main Confederate Army under General Robert E. Lee had gone from victory to victory to victory,” said Guelzo.

At Gettysburg, “the opportunity was there for Robert E. Lee to win a major victory over a Union army. And if he did that, then the political fallout for that victory for the Confederates might in fact have forced President Lincoln to the negotiating table.”


Leave a comment

Filed under Articles

Gettysburg Commemorates its 150th

Civil War buffs and enthusiasts: don’t forget to attend the events in Gettysburg from June 18 until July 7 commemorating the 150th anniversary of the Battle! For those who can’t attend, see this link:


B.J. Small for The Sentinel, June 25, 2013:

This historic Southcentral Pennsylvania town of 7,000 people is bracing for its most significant invasion since the armies of the North and South collided July 1-3, 1863.

As many as 200,000 visitors are expected to be in Gettysburg between June 28 and July 7 to take in some of the 400 scheduled events commemorating the 150th anniversary of the turning point battle of the Civil War.

“The eyes of the world are on us,” said Norris Flowers, president of the Gettysburg Convention and Visitors Bureau.

Limiting congestion and getting visitors to where they want to go have been the biggest logistical challenges for anniversary planners, considering there will be days when as many as 35,000 people could be in town. A major objective is keeping traffic moving through Lincoln Square, where the crossroads for many of the activities tend to narrow.

The primary strategy in a 100-page traffic management plan for the 10-day period employs a generous network of satellite parking areas, and encouraging visitors to use an expanded Freedom Transit shuttle system.

“Our goal is to keep autos out and all the people in,” said Rich Farr of the York-Adams Transit Authority.

“Do some homework before coming to Gettysburg,” urged Carl Whitehill, media relations manager for the Gettysburg CVB. “Figure out what you want to do, where it is and the best way to get there. If you are heading straight to the re-enactment from Carlisle on July 4-7, you don’t need to come into the square in Gettysburg, necessarily.”

Satellite parking and Freedom Transit pickup will be available at Harrisburg Area Community College and Gettysburg High School lots on Old Harrisburg Road/Business Route 15, Gateway Gettysburg at the intersection of Route 15 and 30, Outlet Shoppes at Gettysburg at the intersection of Route 15 and 97, and the Eisenhower Hotel on Route 15, south of Gettysburg. Buses to both re-enactments will run from the community college and high school parking lots.

The Gettysburg CVB will use social media and radio station Great Country 107.7 for real-time updates.

A tourist area that usually welcomes 3 million visitors annually, Gettysburg is expecting 4 million guests throughout the 150th anniversary year. Carl Whitehill, of the CVB, said while there are a few open hotel rooms in town due to cancellations, visitors are making reservations as far away as Harrisburg and Hagerstown, Md.

“We often remind ourselves to put this in perspective of how big this is and how much attention is on us,” Whitehill said. “We need to enjoy this a little bit. We all will have our nose to the grindstone for 10 days, but I think we need to make sure we look up once in a while and enjoy this because we are part of a very significant moment in Gettysburg history. It’s exciting to be in the home stretch.”


The Gettysburg CVB website, http://www.gettysburgcivilwar150.com, is the source for information about the 150th anniversary in Gettysburg and a complete list of events.

Whitehill said planners have honed in on five “signature” events that will attract the largest crowds and demand the most of its transportation infrastructure.

Re-enactors from 16 countries will take to the fields of the David Redding farm on Table Rock Road, north of Gettysburg, for the National Civil War Battle Re-enactment, July 4-7, to bring history alive for tens of thousands of spectators.

It is the anniversary’s single largest activity.

For the 150th anniversary, a fourth day was added to this traditional event. This is the 18th year the Gettysburg Anniversary Committee has produced re-enactments. Planning for this year’s revival began five years ago, after the 145th anniversary event closed.

As many as 12,000 re-enactors are expected to participate in this year’s extravaganza. About 400 horses have been registered and 135 full-sized cannons will be used.

Two battles will be fought each day. Soldier and civilian re-enactors will re-create the 1860s through cavalry, infantry and artillery battles, encampments and demonstrations. Visitors can get an up-close look at cavalry, artillery and the lives that soldiers led during the Civil War, as well as hear period music and ghost stories, see Civil War weddings and medicine demonstrations, and get the chance to eavesdrop on discussions by military officers.

A highlight of the final day, July 7, is the battle “The High Water Mark” Pickett’s Charge at 3:30 p.m.

“Gettysburg is the Mecca for Civil War re-enacting, and this may be the last mega re-enactment with these kind of numbers the public will ever see,” event organizer Randy Phiel said. “As we move further from the Civil War and ancestors who fought in it, re-enacting is an aging hobby with young folks not replacing at the rate of retirements, and the economics cost. I know for many re-enactors this is their swan song.

“Re-enacting is not going away, especially at Gettysburg,” Phiel said.

New re-enactment

A new battle re-enactment for the 150th anniversary was organized by the Blue-Gray Alliance and will take place on the Bushey Farm, south of Gettysburg near the intersection of Pumping Station and Bullfrog roads, June 27-30.

It is estimated that more than 7,000 re-enactors will participate, and spectators are estimated to number in the thousands. Actual re-enactments will be presented June 29 and 30 only. The site is closed to the public on June 27 and 28 when re-enactors will perform “practice runs” of the scenarios.

Battle action includes fighting near McPherson’s Ridge, Culp’s Hill, Devil’s Den, Little Round Top, Wheatfield and Pickett’s Charge.

“We believe history is real. We experience it first-hand,” overall commander General Terry Shelton said. “And this event is an opportunity for the public to really immerse themselves in the experience.”

For more information, go to http://www.bluegraygettysburg.com.

A commemoration ceremony at the Gettysburg National Military Park that features country music star Trace Adkins and historian Doris Kearns Goodwin on Sunday, June 30, will serve as a prelude to many of the 150th anniversary events.

The program “Gettysburg: A New Birth of Freedom” will be free, outdoors and public, near General Meade’s headquarters on Taneytown Road, beginning at 7:30 p.m. with a musical prelude.

Adkins will perform the national anthem, backed by the U.S. Military Academy Orchestra. Goodwin will deliver the keynote address. The ceremony will also include a “Voices of History,” dramatic reading of eyewitness accounts written by soldiers and citizens swept into the events of the Battle and its tragic aftermath.

The gathering will proceed to the Soldier’s National Cemetery to view luminaries marking each of the more than 3,500 graves of soldiers killed in the Battle.

Seminary Ridge

The new Seminary Ridge Museum will open on Monday, July 1, 150 years to the day that fighting raged on its grounds and the structure was thrust into service as the battle’s largest field hospital. Its historic cupola was used as a lookout point during fighting.

The museum on the campus of the Gettysburg Lutheran Theological Seminary tells the story of the early stages of the battle, Civil War medicine, and the role that faith played in the conflict.

Skirmishes, an encampment, living history, period music and the Virginia History Mobile exhibit will be on the grounds for three days, beginning Saturday, June 29. Camps open at noon.

The grand opening and ribbon cutting on July 1 will take place at 10 a.m., followed by a ceremonial cannon-firing.

On July 3, a Pickett’s Charge commemorative march will put visitors in the footprints of soldiers on both sides of the fateful attack, at the Gettysburg National Military Park, from 3 to 4:30 p.m.

Nine National Park Service rangers will lead groups from Seminary Ridge, representing each of the Confederate assaulting brigades, across the same fields of destiny on July 3, 1863. Across the way, three rangers will assemble groups on Cemetery Ridge, where men of three Union divisions awaited the attack.

Other events are planned on the battlefield during the anniversary.

Living history encampments of two full battalions of Union and Confederate infantrymen, with artillery, will present demonstrations near the Pennsylvania Monument and Pitzer’s Woods throughout the days, July 1-3.

Key moment programs from July 1-4 will be 30-minute overviews of action at specific locations on the day of certain battles, such as McPherson’s Ridge, Barlow’s Knoll, Little Round Top, Devil’s Den and the High Water Mark. Shuttles will move visitors from the stadium lot at Gettysburg College to program sites.

Also on the schedule are overview hikes and “Voices of Battle” audio eyewitness accounts of the soldiers and civilians who experienced the tragedy of the battle.

A Confederate field hospital will be set up at the historic Daniel Lady Farm on Hanover Road, June 28 to July 4, for visitors to see demonstrations of pill making during the 1860s and minor surgery, such as bullet extraction, amputations and more.

Actor Stephen Lang will perform “The Wheatfield,” the personal story of a Medal of Honor recipient, at the Park Museum and Visitor Center, Taneytown Road, July 1 at 7 p.m. The world premiere of the short film “The Wheatfield,” written and acted by Lang, will follow.

An Independence Day Parade will make its way through downtown Gettysburg on July 3 at 7 p.m.

The 1938 dedication of the Eternal Light Peace Memorial, off Mummasburg Road, will be commemorated on June 29 at 2 p.m., with Major General Anthony Cucolo, commandant of the U.S. Army War College, as the featured speaker. The Old Guard U.S. Third Infantry will also participate.

A free, commemoration Family Festival will take place at Adams County Winery, 251 Peach Tree Road, Orrtanna, on June 29, at 1 p.m., featuring living history figures, local authors, re-enactors, live music, family- and children-related activities, and official 150th anniversary wines.

On July 6, from 5 to 9 p.m., Confederate re-enactors will again take over the Shriver House on Baltimore Street in Gettysburg, as the original troops did during the Battle. Visitors will be able to learn first-hand from re-enactors. It is the only re-enactment in town at the place where original action occurred.

Special showings of the movies “Copperhead” and “The Gettysburg Story” will be offered at the Majestic Theater on Carlisle Street in Gettysburg throughout the 10 days.

Stage productions of the new Civil War drama “Children of Gettysburg” and the Broadway musical “The Civil War” will play at the Community Theatre on York Street in Gettysburg through July 6.

A complete schedule of 150th Anniversary events in Gettysburg can be found at http://www.gettysburgcivilwar150.com

Leave a comment

Filed under Articles

Gettysburg Teenager’s Civil War Obsession

Story from WTOP.com, January 2, 2011:

GETTYSBURG, Pa. — Andrew Dalton loves studying the Civil War. More specifically, he’s interested in the Battle of Gettysburg.

You can actually narrow that down even further to the events of the battle that happened around his house.

The 14-year-old’s family moved to Cumberland Township, just outside Gettysburg, when he was 3, and they would ride bikes around the battlefield. Andrew was instantly fascinated, and as he got older and read about the battle, he found he knew many of the locations the historians spoke of.

“What I read, I could see,” Andrew said.

It’s not a hobby. It’s a passion. A passion that fills what was once his parents’ dining room.

A map of the battlefield is spread across a table. Old photos of soldiers, history books and binders bursting with information gathered from the nooks and crannies of history lie about on the map.

But it’s not clutter. Everything has its place as Andrew uses a memoir here and photographic evidence there to connect the dots to complete a picture of a piece of history.

The Gettysburg Area High School freshman volunteers as a researcher and historian with the National Park Service. He has held lectures with several local organizations, and gives his own guided walking tour.

Andrew loves all things Gettysburg, but his specialty has been researching the farms around his home on Park Avenue, and digging up the stories of the people who lived there.

“Not too many people can say history happened in their backyard,” Andrew said.

He first looked into the neighboring Harmon Farm, which is yards away from his parents’ house. Through his research, Andrew found an account of the events at the farm written by Amelia Harmon, who was 17 years old when soldiers marched into town.

The farm was used to house Union sharpshooters at one point, and was later burned down by the Confederates, he said.

He is working on a display for the visitors center to show his findings.

But that’s not where it ends. There are plenty of old farms, and houses, all with civilians who witnessed the battle, and Andrew is working hard, and digging deep, to tell their stories, too.

When he grows up, it’s no surprise that Andrew wants to be an historian, specifically working with the Park Service in Gettysburg. He even hopes to go to Gettysburg College so he doesn’t have to leave his battlefield and his research.

Andrew is getting ready to host another walking tour that’s free to the public through Historic Gettysburg-Adams County. When his tour is available, details will be at the organization’s website, http://www.hgaconline.org.

Leave a comment

Filed under Articles

Gettysburg vs Casino

Daily Mail reporters, September 4, 2010:

The site of the Civil War’s tide-turning Battle of Gettysburg is the scene of a new battlefield – this time between developers who plan to build a casino and Hollywood campaigners opposed to the move.

The plans put forward by Harley Davidson dealer David LeVan wish to create 600 slot machines and 50 gaming tables in an existing hotel and conference centre half a mile from the battlefield.

But ‘Save Gettysburg’ organisers have enlisted the help of filmmaker Ken Burns, actors Sam Waterston and Matthew Broderick and Pulitzer Prize-winning author David McCullough to stop the plans. The group who include 60,000 signatories, say a casino would cheapen the reputation that draws tourists to the town and surrounding 6,000-acre park that mark the site where the battle took place.

Over 160,000 Union and Confederate soldiers fought for three days in summer 1863 – with over 51,000 of them killed, wounded or captured in the bloodiest battle North America has ever seen.

Local residents suggest the casino’s approval would betray the country’s duty to protect the place where soldiers died to save the nation. A previous attempt by LeVan to win a Gettysburg-area casino license was rejected in 2006 amid local outcry.- the area already having several hamburger and fried chicken restaurants nearby.

The stars lending their names to the opposition effort have personal connections to the cause. Burns made the 1990 documentary ‘The Civil War,’ which featured Waterson as President Abraham Lincoln and McCullough’s narration; and Broderick – husband of Sex and the City star Sarah Jessica Parker – starred in the 1989 film ‘Glory,’ about black Civil War soldiers.

Developer LeVan claims his ‘Mason Dixon Resort & Casino’ plans will mirror other successful sites in similar areas and states his new plans can bring tourists, investment and 400 jobs to the recession hit Gettysburg area. ‘Mason Dixon can empower the region and re-energize a struggling county by creating good jobs and new opportunities to attract tourists,’ LeVan told the Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board in a video presentation he introduced and narrated. ‘In doing so, we can lift the economy and the quality of life for our friends, neighbors and guests.’

The board, which is considering Mason Dixon’s application to build the casino, listened to comments from casino principals, supporters and opponents at an acrimonious public meeting near Gettysburg National Military Park. ‘No Casino Gettysburg’ campaigner Susan Starr Paddock begged gaming board members to stop the casino plans. ‘We are asking you to please deny this application, to make your legacy saving Gettysburg,’ More than 390 people were registered to speak, including a tall, white-bearded actor who came dressed as Gettysburg general Confederate Robert E. Lee.

The casino’s backers are already competing with three other groups for a state casino license. Pennsylvania-based casino operator Penn National Gaming Inc. would help finance and run Mason Dixon.

The $75 million plans are pitting resident against resident with signs reading ‘No Casino’ and ‘Pro Casino’ dotting windows throughout the quaint streets of Gettysburg, which attracts more than a million tourists each year for shopping, eating and accommodation.

LeVan, a former Conrail Inc. chairman and well-known local philanthropist and preservationist, lives across the street from the park’s museum and visitor centre.

Speaking to the gaming board, he said Gettysburg is in Pennsylvania’s last untapped gambling market – an hour from Baltimore and Washington – and has a lot in common with another casino site in Vicksburg, where the North won another important Civil War battle in 1863.

A video he presented to gaming board members showed how a casino in Vicksburg has tranformed the area from a struggling Civil War tourist town to one which attracts both tourists and investment in its streets, sewers and qualify of life in ten years.

However, opponents counter that casinos have drawn tourists away from downtown Vicksburg, bankrupting businesses and leaving empty storefronts, and challenged Mason Dixon’s revenue projections as unduly rosy and reliant on area residents of modest means.

n the battle itself, Gen. George Meade’s Army of the Potomac stopped the northward advance by Lee and his Army of Northern Virginia, helping deliver a victory to Union forces. Four months after the bloody victory, Abraham Lincoln gave the ‘Gettysburg Address’ – a speech regarded as one of the greatest in American history which detailed ‘a new birth of freedom’ and a chance for true equality for all its citizens.

Leave a comment

Filed under Articles